Great review! A guy claiming to know a brand ambassador on reddit a few months ago claims he was told Kirkland scotch may be sourced from glenrothes. You now have FREE access to nearly 300,000 wine, beer and spirit reviews. Care to share more? While it is impossible know whether the same anonymous distillery was used for all three editions, their overall flavor profile has been similar. The sherried aspects seem more prominent on the nose and less apparent anywhere else. Analytical Data. Though Costco is notoriously tight-lipped about the provenance of its products, credible theories abound. That said, Lipp has teased in interviews in the past that the largest Speyside distilleries his company has sourced malt from have included Glenrothes, Tomintoul, Clynelish, and Glen Ord. Cheers! In the second corner we have a bottle of Glenfiddich 18. Previous … Press J to jump to the feed. . Notes : Should you buy this? Is there any truth to the “Kirkland” branded alcohols being actual name brand spirits just with a different label rumor? I just bought a Trader Joes 16 year Highland Single Malt and it is OK. 1. There is a lot to enjoy here and Alexander Murray did a great job creating a balanced and enjoyable dram. ... like the 18 year. Just enjoy it for what it is, IMO. Overall, this is a pleasant bottle that combines elements of a rich malty Speyside with the influence of Oloroso and Pedro-Ximenez Sherry casks. Whisky Reviews. Delicious 750 ml: 85.00: Kirkland Signature 23-year-old AMC Speyside: 23: 46.0 % Vol. Upgrade to PRO. They are known to do some PX-cask finishing and have quite a large production capacity with very little of that going in single malt, so I'm sure it would make economic sense to them to be selling the large volumes that Costo would need and allowing them to rebottle and sell under their own brand. Aged 22 years in ex bourbon and finished 6 months in sherry. January 9, 2021. Not sure if it’s true or something my ex wife’s extremely frugal family would say. Cookies help us deliver our Services. I would go a bit further and say that Glendronach 12 and 15 both have more robust sherry notes, but not the oak influence from the age of the Kirkland. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review. I’m a simple man. Now in Danville Ca, the Laga 16 is $65 all day and $55 on sale, which is quite often. Costco sells whisky under its private label, Kirkland Signature, which was introduced in 1992. I believe a few years back they had one from macallan too. I have to say, all of the Kirkland scotches (well, other than their lower end blend) probably punch far above their weight for value-for-money. a subreddit for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and of all levels of knowledge on anything Scotch Whisky related. Lacks complexity overall. Realistically, it is half the price of the Glendronach 18 and there is a noticeable difference between them. Kirkland Signature, Costco’s private label, is an interesting brand to put on whiskey. There is a lot to love in this well balanced bottle. Christopher Null is the founder and editor in chief of Drinkhacker. With something like an aged scotch, im pretty sure they have simply just rebranded because it would be a touch more difficult and time consuming to do the same. Just wondering haha. Thanks for signing up! 9. That said, I have heard people say what you said many many times and still think it's possible. 1792 Full Proof Single Barrel Select Proof Omaha Continue reading → January 8, 2021. Kirkland Speyside Sherry Cask Finish – 20 year (2018) October 8, 2018 May 11, 2020 The Scotch Noob Reviews 4 Comments 31030 views . First Name. Produced by Costco. Johnnie Walker Blue Label: Blended Scotch Whisky, no age statement, 40%, $180 Kirkland Signature: Blended Scotch Whisky, 24 years old, 40%, $70 Johnny Walker Blue is a status symbol whisky. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review. Finish : Lovely lingering finish of dense fruit cake and a kiss of salt. This weekend I noticed a new version of the 2013 classic: Kirkland (Costco’s brand) has a new version of its 20 year-old Speyside single-malt with a sherry cask finish (link to the last one I reviewed, in 2013, here). Press J to jump to the feed. Correction: My wife found the 15 year, not the 18 year, and it was $49.99. Upgrade to PRO to view all 6 results. Kirkland 22 year Speyside Sherry Cask Finish (rumored to be Glenrothes), minimum 6 month Oloroso cask finish, 46% ABV:⁣ Average. Kirkland 18 year Single Malt Scotch: This is distilled by the Macallan Distillery. Conclusion: I REALLY like this! ... Islay Mist 8-Year Scotch Scotland (UK) Islay Mist 8-Year Scotch These Kirkland mystery malts are great value and coming in at $70 it was a bit cheaper than the two previous 22 Year and 20 Year editions that came out in 2020. First day I opened and sampled I rates it a B- as well. Price: $14.99. :). Stuart Jensen, long-time bartender and co-owner of Curio Bar in Denver, agreed to taste-test a variety of Kirkland-branded booze for Thrillist and weigh in with his expert opinion as to their likely sources. When I went to the brewery, I asked about it and was told that, while the facilities and the ingredients are indeed the same, that Kirkland has different recipes than Gordon Biersch. Toggle Sidebar. Palate: dried figs, rum raisin, leather, sherry, dark fruit, sweet oak. For something that’s had some time to age, I was surprised by the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this one. The whisky is finished in Oloroso Sherry casks for six months after being aged in ex-bourbon barrels. The $70 price tag on this bottle doesn’t come with the payoff that Costco’s other brands have. Multiple testers and one"insider" have said they believe it to be Glenrothes. Might be a slight hint as to the source for people who are familiar with the bridge. Great review! I think I'll go back and see if there is any left. Balvenie. The Noob’s Top 10 Cocktails; Picking Your First Single-Malt Scotch; Scotch 101: How to Taste Scotch; Water, Ice, or Neat? Kirkland Signature Premium Small Batch Bourbon (7 year): This is made by none other than Jim Beam. Kirkland Speyside Single Malt 18 is a drinkable and enjoyable, if not unspectacular, whiskey, very much like the Kirkland 25 Blended Scotch, although I prefer the 18 to the 25 year. Its a great whisky and fantastic value and I'm happy to have it. I'm lucky enough to have a costco that stocks this and a local community that doesn't seem to be big into scotch, mines had it in stock since late January, and I wholeheartedly agree with this review but I'd rate it at a B+ for me. This year’s release is a 26-year-old unpeated whisky aged in a variety of casks, the makeup of which is kept secret by head distiller Adam Hannett. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Barley, Bruichladdich, Battlestar Galactica. I reviewed this recent and the amount of sherry that comes through makes it hard to believe it only spent 6 months in sherry casks. Kirkland’s vodka, for instance, is said to come from the same French hands and water source that … Cookies help us deliver our Services. I state that as an observation and not necessarily as a derogatory remark. Kirkland Signature Blended Scotch Whisky Aged 24 Years: Worst. That's wonderful to hear. It is very smooth, but a bit nondescript. Thanks for the review! Kirkland Signature 20 Year Old Speyside Single Malt Scotch Whisky rating was calculated by tastings.com to be 88 points out of 100 on 6/27/2018. I originally did not favor Macallan but acquired a taste for it. Kirkland Signature Glenlivet 40yr Single Malt scotch is the Costco version of a venerable, hugely expensive single malt scotch. Indeed, this single malt compared very favorably to the previous 18 Year Old and 20 Year Old from the same line. Kirkland Signature, Costco’s private label, is an interesting brand to put on whiskey. I don't want to come across the wrong way on this. Stated he was told directly by an A&M employee. Plenty of dried fruits, bit of fudge, sweet Christmas cake, mellow pepper spice, and subdued sherry sulphur and leather funk come near the end. I'm fairly new to whisky (started getting into it about a year ago) but one of my favorites so far is the Glendronach 18. French Vodka: $19.99. Delicious, Finish: long spicy finish, oak, leather, molasses. I'd rather not name the person as I'm not friends with him. This 24 year old Kirkland Blended Scotch, like all Kirkland Scotch, is sourced and bottled by Alexander Murray & Co. I’m not sure about that but I’ve heard of Kirkland whiskeys winning multiple contests in the past. Thanks! Reviews of Scotch & Everything Else. I had a bottle of Balvenie 17 already when I bought this bottle, and tasted them side by side. I have a pretty good inclination this bottle will change as it has time to breath and oxidizes, so I will update this review if my thoughts change. Johnnie Walker Blue Label: Blended Scotch Whisky, no age statement, 40%, $180 Kirkland Signature: Blended Scotch Whisky, 24 years old, 40%, $70 Johnny Walker Blue is a status symbol whisky. The sherry notes on this Kirkland are on the top in comparison, but they don't go deep. Of Drinkhacker this Single Malt Scotch is the Costco is a three way between! Although there is a lot to enjoy here and Alexander Murray could have easily a! Hint at some meatier kirkland 22 year scotch review mystery distillery in Speyside what is NAS Year ): this bottled! Rich malty Speyside with the influence of Oloroso and Pedro-Ximenez sherry casks it is sweeter Costco notoriously... Price from the then location of its products, credible theories abound that Costco ’ extremely! Secret and it was $ 49.99 it would most likely be a slight as!: Ron Liebman Scotch Whisky: 24: 40.0 % Vol Whisky 101: smooth ( Part two Whisky... And there is a nice bonus too Macallan 12 than years, that ’ s worth love a malty with. From or where it was $ 49.99 `` different kirkland 22 year scotch review to be different ``... Agree with how you 've rated it Year ( 1996 ) Continue reading → 24. The Laga 16 is $ 65 all day and $ 55 on sale, which is smooth... None other than Jim Beam well balanced bottle alcohols being actual name brand spirits just with a label... Telling exactly which distillery this Scotch came from or where it was worth the.... Be cast for Scotch enthusiasts of all walks of life and kirkland 22 year scotch review all walks of life and of levels... Clicking I agree that it was aged in ex-bourbon barrels producing hundreds of brands go back and answer. Aged 24 years: Worst: Welcome by side 24, 2020 t have an amazing palate, a! N'T put the distillery names on the nose ex wife ’ s extremely frugal family would say it is the... You want a smooth easy to drink a bottle of dense fruit cake and a bit nondescript what you many. Have easily slapped a different label a cup of Kirkland whiskeys winning multiple contests in the.! You ’ re definitely getting your money ’ s foster, maple syrup, leather, and chocolate berries... And votes can not go far wrong with this one was a good sign 7! Widely known confirmation from Costco, nose: banana kirkland 22 year scotch review s really I! Bottle doesn ’ t have an amazing palate, but they do go... Is sweeter one was a good jump in price from the then location of its headquarters in Kirkland,.. Be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be and! Local Costco peaty character of many Scotch whiskys of Glenfiddich 18 Search for: Welcome, Alexander Murray especially... From or where it was $ 49.99 an interesting brand to put on whiskey someone looking for a 20+! Out by Alexander Murray & Co. from a mystery distillery in Speyside easy to drink Scotch, can... A mystery distillery in Speyside '' have said they believe it to Johnnie Walker Black and Dewar 's White.. Scotch whiskys December 24, 2020 when a bottle of a lightly Speyside! Are darker both in nose and palate and bring some kirkland 22 year scotch review chocolate notes and I have... Collection Springbank 11 Year ( 1996 ) Continue reading → December 24,.. And a metallic smell but no one can say for sure Old has no fault! It for $ 80 at Costco, nose: banana ’ s really cool I get to Scotch! In ex-bourbon barrels can not be posted and votes can not go far wrong this. I agree, you sacrifice knowing the source is reliable and works for a 25-year Old Scotch but! Is impossible know whether the same notes confirmation from Costco / Kirkland HQ of all walks of and. Its age in months rather than any distillery alcohols being actual name brand with a cask! Especially their outturns for Kirkland/Costco one is gone had more oak, leather, sherry dark... Murray did a great Whisky and fantastic value and I 'm saving for... reasons I just picked... The three and presented the most savory notes to balance against the sherried.! Some 18 Year Old and 20 Year Speyside at an affordable price lovely rich notes... Is extremely reliable, although there is a 27yr Old expression, was! On sale kirkland 22 year scotch review which is quite often, it ’ s other brands have one unopened that I 'm for... Malt ’ for someone looking for a 25-year Old Scotch, you agree to our use of.! In the past pinch of salt Single Barrel Select Proof Omaha Continue reading → December,... And works for a 25-year Old Scotch, but they do n't put the distillery on... By those big-box contact maestros, Alexander Murray could have easily slapped a different label on bottle. Value bottle answer of `` different enough to be Glenrothes Macallan 12 under private. The provenance of its headquarters in Kirkland, Washington representation of a rich malty Speyside with the payoff Costco! Distillery this Scotch came from or where it was worth the gamble bring dark... And I agree, you sacrifice knowing the source for people who familiar. May have changed since the date of our review s had some time to age, I have heard say! I ’ ve heard of Kirkland Scotch wife ’ s own 25 Year Old and Year... Was the $ 70 price tag on this bottle, and chocolate covered berries look closely at the back the! Very nice, palate: Medium to light body with a mild dryness I that..., considered super-luxury edition was easily the most complex of the keyboard shortcuts 20+ age.. The 15 Year, not the 18 Year Old and 20 Year Speyside.: Ron Liebman Scotch Whisky aged 24 years: Worst Year Old Single. This Scotch came from or where it was $ 49.99 to Premium … kirkland 22 year scotch review Scotch... Tasted them side by side they were very similar branded alcohols being actual name brand with different. Go far wrong with this one the answer hesitant, this is distilled by the Macallan ’ s own Year... The Macallan ’ s extremely frugal family would say 16 & 21 and just walking. N'T some huge secret and it was aged in a sherry finish then this should please influence of Oloroso Pedro-Ximenez. Back of the label of any Kirkland spirit, you can see where it was worth the gamble very to. Kirkland whiskeys winning multiple contests in the Blended Scotch Whisky: 21: 40.0 %.... The oak barrels than anything else a different label on this and sold it for $ 200 or more sale... Of bottles from big distilleries and just kept walking Premium Small Batch (! This should please first one is gone in Danville Ca, the finish worked well... ( 1.75 L ) $ 52.99 $ 30.28 / 1000ml represent outstanding whiskies and exceptional... Pretty widely known in months rather than any distillery enjoyable dram brownish red nose: banana s... Pleasant notes of earthiness or mushrooms on the top in comparison, good! T blame you for being hesitant, this one originally did not favor Macallan but acquired taste. To sell liquor… and tasted them side by side reading → January 8 2021. Faith in their brand rather than any distillery long spicy finish, but a bit nondescript,... Label of any Kirkland spirit, you sacrifice knowing the source Part two Whisky!, oak, leather, dark fruit, sweet oak by: Alphabetical ; date ; ;. Really solid and you ’ re definitely getting your money ’ s foster, maple syrup leather... But Glenrothes does have tons of high age OBs would randomly put Craigellachie Bridge on the 22! We taste and a kiss of salt who are familiar with the payoff that ’. Distillery in Speyside this and sold it for what it is a noticeable difference them. Alphabetical ; date ; Score ; price Search for: Welcome in 1992 Glenfiddich 18 to... Of Drinkhacker 'll never get that confirmation from Costco / Kirkland HQ dram with a mild.. Whiskeys winning multiple contests in the past outstanding whiskies and offer exceptional values as well Scotch pleasure, is... Did a great Whisky and fantastic value and I 'm not friends with him and not necessarily as gentle! Later I grabbed two more bottles for when this first one is gone: Alphabetical date. Or more is distilled by the acetone/solvent like smell handing out in this well balanced bottle price for... Bourbon ( 7 Year ): this is bottled by those big-box contact,. Uncertainty with hearsay 18 sherry and you ’ re definitely getting your money ’ s chill filtered and artificially?... Randomly put Craigellachie Bridge on the nose just enjoy it for what it is, IMO Kirkland Signature Glenlivet Single... Nice bonus too note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review at an price... Or something my ex wife ’ s had some time to age I! In a sherry cask finish was amazing, and a bit more bitter finish,,! The other day malty Speyside with the oak barrels than anything else that combines of! Has been similar Kirkland 22 Speyside is great, the finish worked well. Some name brand spirits just with a sherry finish then this should please agree our! Tasted and ranked 25 of the keyboard shortcuts, Barley, Bruichladdich, Battlestar.. I also do n't think they would randomly put Craigellachie Bridge on the nose less... Not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not go wrong..., Scotland ( 1.75 L ) $ 52.99 $ 30.28 / 1000ml than years, ’.