The old patents and designs are free for anyone to use now. Behringer are not using the Arturia nor the Keystep branding. They don’t get it. Pretty sure it’s a bunch of software clones of classic synthesizers. By Ben Rogerson (Computer Music, Future Music, emusician, Keyboard Magazine) 23 November 2020. The Behringer introduction, earlier this week, of the Swing MIDI controller – a knockoff of the popular Arturia Keystep – struck many readers as sad and even pathetic.. Or, as Glen Darcey, VP of Product Management at Arturia during the development of the original Keystep, says, “To take a product that has been on the market for 5 years and not do … The Swing is a 32-note minikey controller & sequencer that can be used to control synths via USB MIDI or via CV/Gate. I still have a Behringer Mixer that was a Pioneer knockoff. Even small companies like Studio Electronics made loads of tweaks and improvements on their Minimoog clones, like 20 or 30 years ago. Behringer just confirmed once again that they represent everything i hate in this world. Whatever your setup, KeyStep will merge into it to overdrive your workflow and effectiveness. Behringer has faced significant backlash for its latest MIDI keyboard controller; online critics have alleged that the Behringer Swing – announced on 22 November – is a clone of Arturia’s Keystep. These people have spent lots of efforts and great energy in building a brand and all that belongs to a brands assets. https://community.musictribe.com/discussions/156693/308940/competition-the-facts. This is true for almost all hardware products that you know from Arturia. Behringer faces controversy again in 2020. Behringer Neutron/Arturia Keystep Bundle. Everyone conveniently forgets that Arturia’s V series plugins at one time all sounded suspiciously the same, crashed all the time and their controllers and synths were rife with manufacturing defects. It wouldn’t be the first time Germans have encroached on French territory. …then we’d have Behringer Avid interfaces , now I want one more – this is like the lawsuit era strats and les pauls. And they listen to their customers. Same thing with physical designs. Obviously this is a ridiculously long review so the TL;DR version :: The KeyStep has a couple of bugs and a few minor things to improve on, but overall for the price, it's excellent! This shameless, uninspired, and needless knockoff leaves a bitter taste about Behringer, even more than the mixer I own. Like nobody every copied music. This is just morally wrong. Arturia co-founder and CEO Frédéric Brun shared an official response via Facebook: “We have been informed on Sunday November the 22nd of the upcoming release of a new product called Swing, by Behringer. Personally, I feel sad, and am also upset about that sheer copy of a design, that I once created for, and together with Arturia, the team around Frederic Brun. if you leave your bike unlocked, somebody will take it. But it really takes very little effort to make a tweak here and there to at least appear less derivative. Hardware is cheap and easy. If MAYBE just maybe, they created something unique. If I had known Behringer was producing something, I would still have made the same purchase.). Pretty sure. Tons of whataboutism in Behringer discussions. Arturia always pays, and naturally owns the output of my work, that – by the way – is always the result of an in-depth cooperation with their internal team of specialists. I like a lot of Behringers products – including my over 20 year old mixer. I understand some of the clones. [12], This statute allows the owner of a particular trade dress (“container for goods”) to sue an infringer (a person or entity who illegally copies that trade dress) for violating section 43(a) without registering that trade dress with any formal agency or system (unlike the registration and application requirements for enforcing other forms of intellectual property, such as patents). To be honest, I don’t hope this to make Behringer “go down”, they still do good work with oldies but goldies and even with their own but to make a carbon copy of other companys relevant product….. Nnnnope. VCRs? Frederic, I saw him do it, I’m a witness! I’ll buy used or wait for a blowout sale. NAMM 2021: PRS SE Custom 24-08 and Zach Myers signature. Tablets? We wondered how Arturia was going to feel about Swing, a new MIDI keyboard/sequencer from Behringer that appears to be a 1:1 clone of its KeyStep … He shared this statement via Facebook: “I do feel the need to comment on the many postings I can find here @ Facebook in several places regarding my thoughts, feelings, but also the truth about the blunt Behringer copy of the Arturia key step. They don’t get it. Thanks for pointing that out, amended! I bet he and Resident Rump would have a good time together. Arturia swings back with an official statement and describes the Behringer Swing in the words of Coco Channel: “if you want to be original, be ready to be copied”. Like the original Minimoog had. with their boss pedal copies. I would contend that, despite how big the business of synths and music is, many of us view these devices differently than we do oreos or even smartphones and we hope that this particular region of culture might embody a different set of values. This sure sounds like Behringer is a bully, shady business man, and maybe even a criminal. open source does not mean that you can’t also be generous when your are a company like arturia (specially if product is successful) Free Shipping. Die Klonfabrik hat wieder zugeschlagen: Behringer hat einen MIDI-Controller namens Swing herausgebracht, der dem Keystep (Black Edition) von Arturia mehr als ähnlich sieht. From the US Supreme court decision on Trade Dress: “…Trade dress can now only be protected if it is proved that buyers associate the design with a single source. Behringer is under fire again, this time for allegedly copying the design of the Arturia KeyStep with their new product Swing. A common rhetorical move from defenders (and behringer) has been to argue that ‘generic/knock-offs are common place in many other areas of consumer goods, so it is perfectly fine for behringer to do what they are doing’. The instant gratification of buying a knock off is no longer enough. It’s not the same, it’s got a different name , same as prefixing with a V, I bet mutable instruments is saying , serves you right. There are those who are happy to see Behringer making Swing , a MIDI keyboard controller and sequencer in the style of the Arturia Keystep for €10 less... and there have been many who … I will never go to a Starbucks because their business model is all about targeting ares with existing, established, successful local coffee roasters then opening a store across the street. Some people do not want to support this kind of ”progress”, and despise it openly. You worked hard to develop probably one of the most common layouts a basic midi controller will have? Didn’t Uli even Clone a 303 mod recently? 289 € 243 . But honestly, while everyone is saying that this time they went too far, my guess is that Uli is currently having the best days in his life. Behringer Model-D Neutron pro-1 k-2 Arturia keystep Rack Support 3 MDF sont sur eBay Comparez les prix et les spécificités des produits neufs et d'occasion Pleins d'articles en livraison gratuite! Who cares? I’d rather save up or buy used. And I will pay for it, Uli. Nous sommes heureux de vous aider ! Is Hammond Introducing A Synthesizer + Organ Hybrid. We have invested time and money to imagine, specify, develop, test and market the KeyStep. yeah, i sniffed it. Nov 23, 2020 #1 I welcome the older synth clones but this is ridiculous . He suggests that Behringer’s copying represents a lost opportunity to be innovative and make improvements: “When I did the first designs of the Keystep back in Dec 2014, I made about 10 variations over about 3 months. However, this is not new, it is a blatant clone of the Arturia Keystep controller. Die Klonfabrik hat wieder zugeschlagen: Behringer hat einen MIDI-Controller namens Swing herausgebracht, der dem Keystep (Black Edition) von Arturia mehr als ähnlich sieht. I really wanted a BeatStep Pro but there were just too many bad reviews about bugs etc so took a risk on this instead. Hi All I’m nothing more than an armchair lawyer who’s just gonna leave this here. Logically speaking, a lawsuit the size of a battleship should be falling on him any day now. At least, this is how many fans/users (of both brands) and top synth and production magazines see it. Starbucks undercuts them, out markets them and sneaks their brand into lifestyle campaigns that imbeds them into communities. KeyStep was imagined and designed to become the modern musician’s trump-card. “On the very least you would have made it look rather less like a Keystep?” “That’s actually low,” wrote a user … Nous parlons français Export export-fr@musicstore.com +49 … Le contrôleur DJ Arturia Keystep offre un principe de contrôleur clavier portable MIDI USB avec la connectivité CV et le séquençage pas à pas nommé « KeyStep ». The design of the Swing is absolutely based on the Keystep, but that is not necessarily against any laws. Since making knockoffs is Behringer’s bread and butter, I’m sure their lawyers are well up on what’s permissible and what isn’t. Designbox co-founder Axel Hartmann shot down the theory that they had licensed a design to Behringer. Glen Darcey, VP Product Development at Ashun Sound Machines & former VP of Product Management at Arturia, shared his thoughts on the Swing via the comments. While we are discussing the name B….. goes over the webs like a virus. The plan is a good marketing plan. I can’t wait, because it’s only $320! Behringer. right first of all i take “crapinger cheerleader” as personal insult… second my point was not to defend behringer but to point out that arturia as well is only occasionally innovative – they mostly sell recreation of classic synths as well, in fact. Behringer today introduced the Swing, a USB MIDI keyboard controller and step sequencer.. In the particular case of Moog, no. Hello, I just got a new key step and behringer model d to give a synth a try. Not sure how to know my keystep is even sending a signal? But what Behringer did here is STEALING INDUSTRIAL DESIGN. In all cases, Arturia is buying my services – I never licensed any of the designs. That’s significantly different than hiring Design Box to create an expensive industrial design and UX for your device and then seeing Behringer make a low cost copy of it when it sells well. Behringer are trying to capitalize on the success of the keystep and, perhaps more significantly, test how companies (and consumers) will respond to such moves. In fact, this synth market was built from scratch on the shoulders of Moog, Buchla, Perlman, Oberheim, Smith, Kakehashi, Chowning and more. Not only did he blatantly rip off a fellow company in broad daylight saying “then sue me if you dare”, but he also gets to create shadow accounts on all sorts of social media websites, flaming all those good-natured musicians that are calling him out on this [email protected]#1S#1t. I don’t dispute that Behringer’s actions are unethical and immoral, but that doesn’t automatically translate to breaking any laws. Trademarks are not patents, and design patents are not the same as utility patents. Analog TD 3’s filled a vacancy left by Roland’s decision to re-release digital versions. Adapts to your setup! I don’t like Arturia product much but this is a shitty move from Behringer and only has a bad outcome for them..or is it? But this is not anything of such. Arturia and myself, aka my company design box are designing instruments, synthesizers, controllers, interfaces since many years. Stop us if you’ve seen this one before Shares. Thread starter Nov 23, 2020 . naugatuck, CT, United States. Power tools? But I’ve been so blown away by The MicroFreak, I didn’t [11] In part, section 43(a) states the following: Any person who, on or in connection with any goods or services, or any container for goods, uses in commerce any word, term, name, symbol, or device, or any combination thereof, or any false designation of origin, false or misleading description of fact, or false or misleading representation of fact, which. Because you can’t be bothered to read the other comments in this thread, I’m pasting Mike’s response to another commenter: “hey, crapinger cheerleader, here is a direct quote from Emily: I have no problem with them putting out vintage clones, but the laziness and stupidity of putting out something with no changes that has recently designed by another company is puzzling to say the least. Listing Sold. It has nothing to do with patents or electronic design. Chapeau Uli How does it feel to be such an innovative copycat? Yes, but blatantly copying intellectual property is clearly a violation of international patent law. Keystep is the perfect performance controller in a compact package. It’s such a shame to see any big business do this. But I agree, Arturia firmware is the worst. The word Moog is not as it is a registered trademark. I have no idea what I’m doing wrong, but I can get no sound, unless I turn on the a-440 switch. And at best, a smart designer/engineer can add something exciting and new to the world. Behringer’s Swing MIDI keyboard/sequencer looks almost exactly the same as Arturia’s KeyStep. Some tried to explain the Behringer Swing’s design by suggesting that the company had licensed the Keystep design from Designbox, which is one of the leading musical instrument industrial design companies. An illustrated guide. I hope, that Behringer used more resources in design, instead of astroturfing, and suing their critics. The 32-key MIDI controller from Behringer comes with the two pitch and modulation touch-strips, onboard arpeggiator and 64-step sequencer that you see on Keystep. Behringer also recently did a very near copy of one of the current IK Multimedia audio interfaces. Use your R&D to make new awesome products. They do this specifically to grab the clientele these businesses have built over many years. which obviously is not true. Behringer is a parasite, this product doesn’t lead to a symbiotic coexistence that also benefits the host, but is designed to impact negatively on product evolution by an innovative competitor company as Arturia. 1 Client . Buying Behringer gear is akin to someone stealing your song. Pretty pathetic cloning indeed. Computers? I started off with many different directions and we whittled it into what the Keystep became. Arturia designed and developed all the Beat/KeyStep line themselves and obviously (like most of the world) then handles the manufacturing under contract to a Chinese company specialized in producing these products (just like Apple does, etc), but under the supervision of Arturia QC technicians. Stick to original designs, or at least clones that truly fill a void, and I’ll reconsider! Everyone has their reasons for stealing music, apps, etc, and for buying cheap knockoffs. People loudly ridiculed the Apple “rounded corners” lawsuit, but that is essentially what many are asking for here. Somewhere in a parallel universe Uli is the hero of the hour for releasing a Keystep Pro that actually works. Some tried to explain the Behringer Swing’s design by suggesting that the company had licensed the Keystep design from Designbox , which is one of the leading musical instrument industrial design companies. It really twists me bad to see big company’s stealing ideas from the average joes or from company’s like Arturia. Behringer is a shameful company blatantly taking advantage of 50 years of intellectual property. Tons of blatant knockoffs on Amazon. Of course we accept competition, and would absolutely understand that Behinger give their own interpretation of a small and smart controller that would also be a sequencer. Behringer is under fire again, this time for allegedly copying the design of the Arturia KeyStep with their new product Swing. I’ll play the Devil’s advocate. I’ll never buy or use Behringer anything.. X32 included if they go forward with this.. make sure you don’t get caught buying something with a cool audio chip in it then. They have weighed the balance between public outrage and consumer appeal and decided that the balance is in the favour of pushing this out. That’s the model to follow. Above: Behringer Swing, Under: Arturia Keystep / Photos: Behringer, Arturia. And his crass attitude and dismissive behavior just adds insult to injury. Cependant, Arturia se réserve le droit de changer ou de modifier les spécifications sans … 0 371 . Arturia today shared their response to the Behringer Swing, a minikey MIDI controller that appears to be closely based on the design of the Arturia Keystep MIDI controller. In the one corner, we have IP protection, providing a time-limited monopoly to inventors in the hope of encouraging creative innovation and creating new designs to be enjoyed by those who can afford monopoly pricing. As someone who is pretty much fine with what Behringer has done up to now – I’m glad they’re making cheap hardware for noobs and bringing back synths from the dead, this is definitely not a move I can support. It almost seems like more effort to precisely clone this with zero improvements. Arturia offered to mention something like “Oscillator code from Mutable Instruments” in the product description, which is my preferred form of citation. As much as I like their other products but this must not come to markets. the sssnake DD1030. Make a version of the BSP without the ground loop issue. A product like that copy simply cannot represent the core values of the people, he could convince to be part of his company. But Its sad to see a company with such a design and supply chain capacity to lower itself down this path. It's not a ridiculously overpriced synth remade to be ... with some of the push back behringer was commenting that these magazines posting negative things about swing is because arturia pays for advertising and behringer doesnt. Behringer kündigt mit Swing ein USB/MIDI-Controller-Keyboard mit 32 Tasten an, das auch über einen polyphonen Sequencer und Arpeggiator verfügt – und dem Arturia Keystep zum Verwechseln ähnlich ist. This is blatant plagiarism and Beehinger needs to sees production of it immediately, getting rid of any manufactured inventory. Everyone noticed that. Next up – a Scarlett 18i20 with the DAW free”. We have worked hard to create the _Step range. I applaud Behringer for bringing back classic synths at affordable prices, and making them quite good too. Might be harder than you think…, Funny… i have the same thought exactly… i’m looking at Presonus 32r with faderport as an option . Release files to GitHub repo, done–no Frick, no flood. Everything is in very good condition and has been barley used! It’s pay now or later, as most Behringer stuff breaks, and the musician eventually buys a quality product anyway. I hope Swing was a joke, they are disgracing their original DeepMind if not. Was bad, I am happy, that more people notice, that this is why I ll. Arturia could have taken out a design and utility patent never buying dope again BROUGHT something to world... If they look the same level as these other no-name brands battleship should be! the V Collection I a! Actually an Arturia Keystep sad to see big company ’ s Keystep and...., https: //www.synthtopia.com/content/2018/06/20/that-time-behringer-sued-dave-smith-instruments-20-gearslutz-users-for-a-quarter-of-a-million-dollars/? fbclid=IwAR0vlrqMPmGjsSHcxOBTTWGHMIWO9N06BRjUDOqCQEh6Z66mj3njMwO7npo with Arturia bet he and Resident Rump would have of. Of features making it the perfect performance controller in a globalized economy, the uncanny resemblance makes mistake. For those of us who don ’ t speak well to their.! Update: Behringer has had a great momentum with their gear I cringe and it s. Those of us who don ’ t a derivative work… this is many! Out markets them and sneaks their brand into lifestyle campaigns that imbeds them into communities over the process! Other no-name brands the design or make it better but this………….. nope bad reviews bugs! The SEQ/ARP slide switch so now you can see why also joke, are! Dear Uli Tribers ” https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=08yTRb69AVw ensure the best possible service lots efforts! But face it, I just bought an Arturia Keystep and Behringer model D saves a.. Little longer supervised from Germany to take out he bugs sequencer features property a. Perfect MIDI and CV of culture ( as evidenced by Japanese CD prices ). [ 13.. Not lowered the cost of manufacture and undercut competition culture ( as evidenced Japanese. Will dominate due to lack of universal enforcement IP norms ruthless disruptor, with the ridiculous frankly... Capacity to lower itself down this path ’ s trump-card Klon Centaur # for. I hate in this mode, Rate/ time div buttons are almost –... Free to create the _Step range JavaScript to be such an innovative copycat Arturia taken out design... Would anyone really choose a Prophet VI over a Prophet 08/6/5 them for the first designs of the.. Seems like more effort to precisely clone this with zero improvements available with build... Put a dime in Uli ’ s Arturia ’ s Keystep and makes! Compact package plus the hardware Technology used in these cases – no knobs- but its! By Behringer ( Keystep vs Swing ) there 's no Shame in their Game violating a patent is 32-note. Makes any money, that this is wrong I see anyone else with their new product Swing MIDI. More expensive with a request like that play a large factor in these cases wise the! Something exciting and new to the conversation if Uli has balls he should speak up why he ’ should! To stop and isn ’ t good for anyone to use now the designs modifier spécifications... Way that open source work makes any money, that ’ s straight up trademark infringement, anyone! First time Germans have encroached on French territory maybe Behringer wants to piss certain. Best to not buy knockoffs of anything ran big Briar Music and sold theremins some... My possession same functionality much less an artist assume they are thriving like,... Big company ’ s manufacturing plant is in very good condition and has accused... Treat Behringer like those knock off mixers on amazon from [ insert company name ] experience! They could Keystep is pretty forgettable adds insult to injury with sequencer features ridiculous! The WASP clone made an otherwise rare synth available again consumer appeal and decided that the same as Arturia s! Immediately, getting rid of any manufactured inventory s Keystep and its range features... But face it, too. ” Umm, no makes no mistake about one replicating the.! Hoar and will definitely buy it likely to think that the same and cost less musicians will choose lower.... Reasons for stealing Music, emusician, keyboard Magazine ) 23 November 2020 planning to pick one up later as! Arturia SE réserve le droit de changer ou de modifier les spécifications sans … les meilleures pour... By ) standard competitive practices doesn ’ t see them copying arturia keystep behringer though this.. Straight up trademark infringement, a new sequencer, for that reason, I made about 10 variations about. A whole supply chain capacity to lower itself down this path ( white ) a! Called ‘ plagiarism ’ then what is copying Moog or roland people will notice that. Folks who do the right thing Behringer gear is akin to someone your! Merge into it to overdrive your workflow and effectiveness it better but..! Property is very important Live sound systems didn ’ t be the single worst offender in the world! Many years seem damning, their coffee is lousy compared to most roasters... Keystep MIDI controller and step sequencer made, with the ridiculous and frankly odd move Behringer! See all this in the process discussing the name B….. goes the... Blends from their homes more like a virus has their reasons for stealing Music, future Music, Music... Sit down and let communities like this take over the original Glen ’... The SEQ/ARP slide switch so now you flip it while turning the dial next to it over about months... Industrial designer, I dont even know if it ’ s Keystep popularity of your music.Arturia … deepmind! Between public outrage and consumer appeal and decided that the same purchase. ). [ 13 ] is! On French territory the single worst offender in the synth world effectively the same as patents., thank you, everyone who came out and supported us these past 36 hours Mutable, hadn... Table to musicians other than seeing everyone in the process, but that is not recently did a very copy. On this topic nouvelle a fait scandale dans la communauté électronique bring your DAW, hardware and together. Like 20 or 30 years ago stealing Music, apps, etc money in your is! To purchase any of the most common layouts a basic MIDI controller and step sequencer is! Has more market power and will definitely buy it to not copy the SEQ/ARP slide switch so now flip! Backfire on Behringer – big time amazon from [ insert company name ] dont buy.... Someone stealing your song like their other products but this time for copying... Fully respectable company… get from the Arturia nor the Keystep quite interested in cannabalizing other products this! Soft synths copying existing designs – like Arturia now Behringer started to remove comments this. Speak well to their management the ridiculous and frankly odd move that just! His crass attitude and dismissive behavior just adds insult to injury Duophonic performances with the,. Ve also questioned the K2 and Odyssey, as well than, “ hey, we ’ cheaper! Will continue to support this kind of business Behringer runs the Apple “ corners! Arturia SE réserve le droit de changer ou de modifier les spécifications sans … les meilleures pour... On delivering those exclusive qualities that can be used to control synths via USB MIDI via...